Planning For Growth and Safer Streets at Bronx Metro-North Stations

Once the MTA’s East Side Access project is finally complete, a few additional upgrades will allow Metro-North’s New Haven Line trains to stop at new stations in the East Bronx and cross the Hell Gate Bridge before heading to Penn Station. The Bronx is also expected to grow faster than any other borough in the coming years. With both factors in mind, the Department of City Planning has released a new report on the potential for transit-oriented development at Metro-North stations in the Bronx.

The study examined the development opportunities and street safety needs aroudn eight existing and proposed Metro-North stations. Image: DCP
The study examined development opportunities and street safety needs around eight existing and proposed Metro-North stations. Image: DCP

The study examines not only potential development but also how to improve access to train stations in neighborhoods divided by highways, rail lines, hills, and superblocks.

The plan focuses on eight Metro-North stations: University Heights and Morris Heights on the Hudson Line; Williams Bridge, Fordham, Tremont, and Melrose on the Harlem Line; and Morris Park and Parkchester/Van Nest on the proposed Hell Gate Line.

“The reason we chose these stations is because they had the greatest capacity for growth,” DCP project manager Shawn Brede told the City Planning Commission during a presentation last week. The borough is projected to have the fastest growth rate in the city, with nearly 200,000 additional residents by 2040, a 14 percent increase over today.

DCP hopes to focus much of that growth in transit-accessible areas, and shifts already underway in the borough’s commuting patterns show why Metro-North stations could be especially important. “The Bronx has the largest reverse commute [population] in the nation, and likely the fastest-growing,” said Carol Samol, director of DCP’s Bronx office. Nearly one in ten working Bronx residents commutes north of the city, according to Census data cited by DCP, and the highest concentration of jobs is along the New Haven Line.

While many Bronxites are commuting to suburban jobs, making it from Metro-North to work often isn’t easy. “When people are going up to these job centers, they get off the train and they can’t make that last mile,” Brede said at last week’s presentation. Planners in Westchester and Connecticut are working on projects funded by the same federal planning grant from the Department of Housing and Urban Development to address these and other issues.

In addition to reverse commutes, the report looks at growing job centers within the Bronx that lack sufficient transit. The area around the proposed Metro-North station at Morris Park is a good example. “It doesn’t have a lot of transit access right now. The majority of people coming in are typically driving to this area,” Brede said.

More than 16,000 workers are already commuting to jobs within a half-mile of the proposed Morris Park station, at complexes such as Hutchinson Metro Center, Bronx Psychiatric Center, Jacobi Medical Center, and Albert Einstein College of Medicine. That number is growing: A new 911 call center and Marriott hotel are under construction nearby.

Adding a new Metro-North station will help commuters, but that’s not enough to get workers to use the train. For the area surrounding the station, the report recommends better sidewalks, a more connected street grid, and requiring first-floor uses like retail, which increase the appeal of walking. Changes could also include allowing denser development near the train station, where semi-industrial uses currently predominate.

DCP floated these ideas at community meetings near Morris Park before writing up the report. “We got a really good response to some additional density,” Brede told commissioners.

The area around Fordham station doesn’t need changes to jumpstart street life — it’s already one of the most vibrant retail hubs in the city. Here, DCP is seeking to reinforce efforts already underway to improve the public realm, and encouraged local organizations to take a closer look at parking management and marketing the area as a regional destination, among other recommendations.

DCP has proposed pedestrian safety fixes near the University Heights Bridge to help improve access to an under-utilized Metro-North station. Image: DCP
DCP has proposed pedestrian safety fixes near the University Heights Bridge to help improve access to an under-utilized Metro-North station. Image: DCP

Not all Bronx Metro-North stations are so well used. The University Heights station, sandwiched between a sloping residential neighborhood, the Major Deegan Expressway, and the Harlem River, saw fewer than 250 riders on an average weekday in 2011. Like train ridership, a long-stalled waterfront development nearby has been stifled by limited access. Pedestrian safety is also a major concern: People trying to walk to the station must contend with heavy traffic coming to and from the Deegan.

“We’ve worked with DOT and we’ve identified some ways that minor improvements could happen: enhancing crossings, greening, channelization of the pedestrian and vehicular corridors,” Brede said at the hearing. DOT told the commission that it is “still reviewing the recommendations.”

The issue is on the minds of advocates. Last weekend, Transportation Alternatives hosted a “street scan” to identify hazards for pedestrians and cyclists using the Harlem River bridges, focusing on the University Heights Bridge. “The big issue is simply that there is too little space dedicated for pedestrians [and] cyclists,” said TA organizer Tom DeVito. “The design clearly leads to avoidable conflicts between multi-ton vehicles and vulnerable street users.”

City Planning Commission Chair Carl Weisbrod was intrigued by the plan. “The potential for these stations to enhance connectivity from one side of the tracks to the other,” he said last week, “particularly in a borough, the Bronx, where the highway and parkway and expressway system has had the opposite impact in the past several decades, is I think a real opportunity here.”

  • Richard Garey

    The PRIMARY factor that prevents greater use of the Metro North in the Bronx is cost. The SECONDARY factor that prevents greater use of Metro North in the Bronx is schedule. Prior to getting all gung-ho about adding greater density to areas surrounding Metro North Stations, I highly recommond you look at River Park Towers and Morrisania Air Rights Housing. The former is built directly adjacent to the Morris Heights Metro North Station. The latter is built directly above the Melrose Metro North Station. These two high density housing complexes have been plagued by crime for decades. Just last week, the Feds arrested 19 members of the “River Park Towers Young Gunnerz” because they allegedly held residents captive to their drug dealing and violent acts. Morrisania Air Rights housing was nicknamed “Vietnam” by local residents due to the high volume of shootings at the complex. Part of the reason the crime is so high at these complexes is that they are considered isolated. Very FEW residents actually utilize the Metro North stations. The fact is that 9 out of 10 ten Bronxites work in the city. Until the MTA either reduces the Manhattan-Bound fare on the Metro North or adds shuttle lines to those tracks, I would be very cautious about adding greater density in these isolated areas.

  • HamTech87

    First, they have to get at the pricing issue. MetroNorth is far too expensive for many workers, so they end up taking subways to the free transfer Bee-Line Bus in Westchester. This makes for unbelievably long commutes.

    Second, they have to get HUD and the state to start doing something about job sprawl. They can’t pay lipservice to better transit, but then build a new TZ Bridge that encourages new manufacturing and distribution centers in Rockland and Orange Counties. If we’re going to give tax breaks to employers, we need to do it in transit-rich locations.

    Third, what ever happened to the new MetroNorth west side stations in Manhattan? The new Columbia campus at 125th Street could use a train station for commuters from these TOD Bronx stations, especially if the price is comparable to the subway.

  • lop

    Well Cuomo dropped Hudson line to Penn when he mentioned Metronorth to Penn a while back so that killed the stop at 125th for now.

    MNR to Penn can’t happen until ESA is finished allowing LIRR to shift some trains crosstown making room for New Haven/Hudson line riders, and that’s what, 8 years away still? Could happen, just not soon.

  • AnoNYC

    Lower the fare within city limits and ridership will skyrocket.

  • lop

    Don’t just lower the fare, have more trains stop. On the LIRR right now Kew Gardens has hourly service at midday. Plenty of trains go past on the mainline, having more stop wouldn’t cause much trouble. Forest hills too, but that station is much closer to the subway so it matters less. For the Bronx stations New Haven trains only stop at Fordham, and doesn’t take passengers between there and Grand Central, due to the operating agreement with CDOT.

  • Perez Brian

    Amen i agree to that as a city résident it would be beneficial to use the metro north but is pricey evenfor à short commuté

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

The East Bronx Doubles Down on Traffic-Oriented Development

|
The East Bronx is on track to get new Metro-North service, but developers are building unwalkable, traffic-generating projects near the stations, fueled by state and city funding for highway ramps and expansions. Unless things change, the new rail service will be marooned in a sea of car-centric sprawl and traffic congestion. The biggest development site, sandwiched between […]

Speak Up for Safer Streets in Brooklyn and the Bronx

|
This week, there are important DOT workshops concerning major streets in Brooklyn — Fourth Avenue in Bay Ridge and Broadway from Myrtle Avenue to the Williamsburg Bridge. There’s also a community board meeting to reconsider a bike corral the board had already approved. Also this week: In the Bronx, the MTA will hold a hearing […]

This Week: The Bronx Talks Transit-Oriented Development

|
Last April, the federal government announced a $3.5 million grant to a consortium of New York and Connecticut governments to promote transit-oriented development. In New York City, planning is focused on commuter rail stations in the Bronx and East New York. Tonight, HUD Regional Director Adolfo Carrión hosts a town hall meeting to gather public input […]

City Begins to Reclaim Space for Pedestrians at Fordham Plaza

|
The multi-year project to improve Fordham Plaza in the Bronx — a critical transit hub — entered its latest phase yesterday with the groundbreaking for a bigger and better public space for pedestrians. Each day, more than 80,000 pedestrians flow through Fordham Plaza, the crossroads of a dozen bus lines (including two Select Bus Service […]

Keep L Train Passengers Moving With Great BRT

|
The news that Sandy-related repairs will require closing one or both directions of the L train under the East River (the “Canarsie Tube”) for one to three years has understandably caused panic among the estimated 230,000 daily passengers who rely on it. Businesses in Williamsburg that count on customers from Manhattan are also concerned about a […]

HUD Grant Will Lay the Groundwork for TOD in New York and Connecticut

|
From Suffolk County to New Haven, the communities of New York and Connecticut are planting the seeds for a serious investment in transit-oriented development in the years ahead. Funded by a $3.5 million grant from HUD’s Sustainable Communities program, nine cities, two counties and six regional planning organizations have come together to develop regional plans […]