NYC Set to Get Safer Streets After Senate Passes Speed Cam Bill, 49-11

Two days after the Assembly passed legislation to expand the number of speed cameras in New York City from 20 to 140, the Senate followed suit this afternoon in a 49-11 vote. Since Governor Cuomo has signaled support for the bill, it is almost certainly bound to become law. The main question is whether a superfluous amendment from Senator Marty Golden will make it into the final version.

The bill keeps tight restrictions on where and when the cameras can be used: They are limited to streets with a school entrance or exit within a quarter-mile, and can only be used during school hours. To placate Golden, the Senate added an amendment that would restrict revenue raised by the cameras to police, fire, and school zone safety initiatives. With the amendment attached, Golden voted for the bill.

According to Newsday, the sudden move to advance the legislation came because Nassau County’s financial plan relied in part on the cameras.

At a press conference outside City Hall this afternoon, I asked City Council members how they respond to speed camera opponents who call them mere revenue-raisers, despite their proven safety benefits. Former transportation committee chair James Vacca took the microphone to put things in perspective.

“If there’s any State Senator that thinks we want cameras at red lights, or speeding cameras, because we are going to use it as a revenue producer, I think they should think again,” he said, noting that revenue falls as drivers get tickets and learn to stop driving recklessly. “This has nothing to do with revenue. We want people to slow down their cars.”

The de Blasio administration would like to secure home rule over automated enforcement, and the City Council Transportation Committee is considering a resolution this afternoon in support of that request. We’ll have more coverage of today’s hearing at City Hall later today.

This post has been updated to reflect the latest vote tally, initially reported in the Senate as 51-9.

  • Realist

    Won’t make a bit of difference. Our steets will remain safe, as they are mow.

    But when the tickets hit the mailboxes, there will be thousands of angry calls coming in to these pandering pols.

  • Ari_FS

    The amendment doesn’t really matter. If it placates some naysayers, fine.

  • Daniel

    140 is so few, but probably enough for 2014. We really do need to get another tens of thousands cameras up soon to reach Vision Zero in the coming decade.

  • Adrian

    You’re right. It’s every New Yorker’s right to drive their unnecessarily large SUVs at 10mph over the speed limit past a school entrance during school hours without facing any consequences, dammit.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Safety of NYC Streets Again Depends on State Senator Marty Golden

|
The Assembly yesterday passed legislation that would expand NYC’s speed camera program by 120 cameras, bringing the total to 140. The bill, which also allows speed cameras in Nassau and Suffolk counties, was referred to the Senate rules committee this morning, bypassing the transportation committee. Rules is the last stop before a bill moves to the floor […]

Looks Like Marty Golden Is Holding Up Speed Cameras, Again

|
Dana Rubinstein at Capital New York reports that State Senator Marty Golden has again emerged as an obstacle to NYC speed cameras. On Monday the Assembly passed a bill that would allow the city to deploy 120 additional cameras, bringing the total to 140. We reported yesterday that the allocation of speed camera revenue was a […]

Albany’s Slimmed-Down Speed Cam Legislation Could Cross the Finish Line

|
This afternoon, the City Council passed a home rule resolution calling on Albany to pass legislation enabling speed enforcement cameras in school zones. The last time there was action on speed camera legislation, more than two months ago, Mayor Bloomberg was chastising state senators Marty Golden, Simcha Felder, and Dean Skelos for torpedoing the program in the Senate’s budget […]