Electeds Want MTA Onboard With Vision Zero After Latest Pedestrian Death

Marisol Martinez was struck by an MTA bus driver as she crossed Union Avenue at Meeker Avenue in Brooklyn. The red arrow represents the movement of the driver and the white arrow the movement of the victim, according to reports and photos from the scene. Image: Google Maps
Marisol Martinez was struck by an MTA bus driver as she crossed Union Avenue at Meeker Avenue in Brooklyn with her cousin and a friend. The red arrow represents the movement of the driver and the white arrow the movement of the victim, according to reports and a witness account. Image: Google Maps

Electeds and advocates called for changes at the MTA and for Mayor de Blasio to focus street safety resources on northern Brooklyn after another pedestrian was killed by a bus driver this weekend.

Marisol Martinez, 21, was crossing Union Avenue at Meeker Street in Williamsburg with two other people at around 1:25 a.m. Saturday when she was hit by a bus driver making a left turn.

“When we were in the middle of the crosswalk, we saw the bus, and we saw it too late,” the victim’s cousin, Jose Gonzales, said at a press conference on Sunday. “We had the right to cross, so I mean, for the bus not to yield, for it not to stop, I don’t know.”

Martinez was at least the tenth pedestrian or cyclist killed by an MTA bus driver in the last 12 months. Photo via ##http://nypost.com/2014/03/01/woman-21-killed-by-bus-in-williamsburg/##New York Post##
Martinez was at least the tenth pedestrian or cyclist killed by an MTA bus driver in the last 12 months. Photo via ##http://nypost.com/2014/03/01/woman-21-killed-by-bus-in-williamsburg/##NY Post##

Gonzales, 22, said he and his friend Jonathan Acosta, also 22, ran to get out of the driver’s path, and barely avoided being hit themselves. Martinez was behind them. She was first hit by the front of the bus, Gonzales said, and was run over by the right rear tire.

“I made it in time, my friend [Acosta] made it in time, but as I turned around at the same time I saw my cousin go down face first and get ran over. It ran over her body, and I didn’t see her anymore on my side. I went around the other side to see her crushed. Her leg was crushed. The flesh was all over the floor. I couldn’t bear to see it. I saw her on the floor. I couldn’t get near her. I couldn’t do anything to help her anymore. My friend screamed for the bus to back up. It never did.”

Acosta told the driver, an unidentified 50-year-old woman, to move the bus off of Martinez, Gonzales said. “She said she couldn’t do anything about it.” The Daily News reported that the bus driver was not charged for turning a bus into a crosswalk where three people were walking. As of this afternoon, a spokesperson told Streetsblog NYPD could not confirm information on charges or summonses, and said the investigation is ongoing.

Martinez was a sophomore at Hunter College and wanted to be a nurse, according to a News 12 report.

Martinez was the third pedestrian or cyclist killed by an MTA bus driver in 2014, and at least the tenth such fatality in the last 12 months, according to crash data compiled by Streetsblog. On Sunday, officials joined loved ones of Martinez, Ella Bandes, and Seth Kahn — who were fatally struck by bus drivers in 2013 and 2009, respectively — at Grand Street and Borinquen Place. On hand were City Council members Steve Levin and Antonio Reynoso and Assembly members Joe Lentol and Martiza Davila.

“We chose the intersection of Grand and Borinquen for this event because it took a number of incidents, including fatalities, before the city made changes to the street design that prioritized pedestrian safety,” said Reynoso via a press release. “It should not take a tragedy to get the city to pay attention; we should be taking a proactive approach that prevents these incidents from happening at all.”

At the press conference, Miller Nuttle of Transportation Alternatives said street improvements such as safer crosswalks and protected bike lanes, along with more traffic enforcement of violations including failure to yield and speeding, would save lives and prevent injuries. “We know that big, wide, fast streets like Meeker Avenue send a signal to drivers to speed and drive recklessly,” said Nuttle. “These types of streets and the crashes that typically accompany them are by no means inevitable.”

North Brooklyn had one of the highest concentrations of traffic deaths in 2013, according to NYPD data mapped by I Quant NY. In addition to making the area a focus of Vision Zero, Levin and Lentol said the MTA must participate. Levin said MTA drivers should be trained to a much higher standard than other motorists.

“We clearly have too many major injuries, fatalities, broken families as a result of bus drivers failing to yield, bus drivers not driving appropriate for such a massive, multi-ton vehicle,” said Levin. “There is no possible reason why a bus driver would fail to yield to a pedestrian.”

Levin said MTA buses should be equipped with a guard that pushes pedestrians out of the path of the rear wheels. He said such guards are already in use in DC, Chicago, and Los Angeles. “That’s something the MTA can do right away,” said Levin. “They could do that tomorrow.”

“The first thing we’re looking for is the cooperation of the MTA, and if we don’t get that cooperation, then they’re looking at legislation to force their cooperation,” said Lentol. “So we’re not going to make it difficult for them in the beginning, but we want to have them as a partner in Vision Zero.”

Streetsblog asked the MTA by email about its investigation into the crash, whether the driver faces disciplinary action, and if the agency will have a role in the implementation of Vision Zero. “We will conduct a thorough investigation,” a spokesperson replied. “DOT has contacted us about Vision Zero and [we] look forward to further discussion.”

Martinez, whose birthday was in January, was the eldest child in her family, Gonzales said. “The last thing we talked, was just about her birthday and how I missed it. Her life just started. She had big plans.”

  • Mike

    Everyone talks about how bad the cab drivers are, but in my opinion as a pedestrian/bike rider MTA bus drivers are the most dangerous thing on the roads. Aggressive and deadly.

  • Aunt Bike

    The driver might just get a summons for failure to yield. Unless the Brooklyn DA thinks he can make a difficult to prove reckless driving charge out of it.

    I see a future where motor vehicle traffic in NYC is going to have to be stopped in all directions to allow pedestrians to cross safely. I just don’t think drivers in general have the ability to make a turn and look out for pedestrians at the same time. I do see plenty of drivers who act like their prerogative is to beat the pedestrian to the crosswalk.

    The data I read on the topic reenforces my belief. Pedestrians struck by cars are most often hit while in the crosswalk, with the signal on their side.* The current system of crosswalks and signals simply do not protect pedestrians from an inattentive driver or one who is so intent on making his turn before the light changes that they don’t notice someone crossing the street. Lead times for pedestrians literally put them in the crosshairs of inattentive, anxious drivers.

    * http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/03/nyregion/study-details-injuries-to-pedestrians-and-cyclists-in-new-york-city.html?_r=0

  • JamesR

    Access-a-Ride is even worse. This is what you get when you combine vulnerable peds and cyclists with locomotive-sized, blind-spot prone vehicles and an aggressive driving culture on city streets.

  • Rabi Abonour

    I feel like MTA buses often drive as though they are on a dedicated right-of-way, as opposed to being in traffic with other vehicles, pedestrians, and cyclists. Add that to the fact that buses are so big and you have a recipe for disaster.

  • StepUpAndSaySomething

    As uniformed, city officials, the MTA knows the NYPD will only enforce the most egregious laws, and then, only if enough people make noise. That brotherhood/corruption needs to end, but the NYPD will fight it tooth and nail, because they fear they will be next to be pulled from being above the law. Having a fair, yet aggressive prosecution would be a real progressive change, but sadly it probably won’t happen yet. Until the, the young and old will be needlessly killed, ripping apart families.

  • bob5

    Every bus should have an outward and an inward facing camera. Every freaking bus. Cuts down on false lawsuits and makes sure the guilty are punished as they surely should be.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Lentol: Safety Improvements Coming to Meeker Avenue in 2016

|
DOT will present safety improvements next month for Meeker Avenue by the BQE in Williamsburg, according to Assembly Member Joe Lentol. The department told Lentol’s office it would bring a proposal to Brooklyn Community Board 1 on January 12. Meeker Avenue runs under the BQE for a mile between North 6th Street and Vandevoort Avenue, dividing […]

The Weekly Carnage

|
The Weekly Carnage is a Friday round-up of motor vehicle violence across the five boroughs. For more on the origins and purpose of this column, please read About the Weekly Carnage. Fatal Crashes (7 Killed This Week; 139 This Year*) East Elmhurst: Melania Ward, 55, Killed by MTA Bus Driver on Astoria Blvd.; No Charges (Streetsblog) UWS: Cydney […]

The Weekly Carnage

|
The Weekly Carnage is a Friday round-up of motor vehicle violence across the five boroughs. For more on the origins and purpose of this column, please read About the Weekly Carnage. Fatal Crashes (2 Killed This Week; 33 This Year; 1 Driver Charged*) Williamsburg: Marisol Martinez, 21, Struck in Crosswalk by Turning MTA Bus Driver (Streetsblog) Brownsville: Philip […]