Motorists Still Pose the Biggest Danger to NYC School Kids

With the new school year in session, an analysis of traffic injury numbers by WNYC shows that NYPD and DOT need to step up on enforcement and engineering improvements to prevent motorists from hurting kids.

Back to school day 2013. Photo: Doug Gordon

Year after year, traffic crashes rank as the leading cause of injury-related death for children in NYC. Drawing on state DMV data from 2009 through April 2012, WNYC found that about 1,800 kids between the ages of five and 17 are struck by city motorists every year, an average of almost five each day. Focusing on the hours of 6:30 to 8:30 a.m. and 2:30 to 4:30 p.m. on school days, when school-age children account for one-third of all pedestrian victims, Coulter Jones and Alex Goldmark report that most kids who were hit were crossing with the signal or mid-block. (The vast majority of adults struck by motorists during those hours were crossing with the signal.)

Data show that 7 percent of injuries before and after school involved kids who emerged — or “darted,” in the victim-blaming parlance of motordom — from between parked cars. Under 4 percent of kids were struck while “playing in roadway,” which was known simply as “playing” before streets were ceded to motor vehicles.

WNYC points out that kids can’t detect the presence of oncoming vehicles or gauge speed as well as adults do, and that in the event of a collision the likelihood of a pedestrian’s survival depends on how fast the motorist is driving.

All of this adds up to an argument for protecting children on their way to school through a mix of education and policy, not just telling kids to look both ways [see Safety City]. Parents and crossing guards can look out for children and teach them to follow traffic rules, but enforcement against speeding and redesigning intersections can also have a dramatic impact.

Injuries to kids have dropped 44 percent near 100 or so schools selected to receive federally-funded Safe Routes to School improvements. But there are 1,200 school buildings in the city, WNYC notes, and Safe Routes funds were reduced in the latest federal transportation bill.

“[T]here are hundreds if not thousands of intersections near schools that have been improved … in the last five years,” DOT Commissioner Janette Sadik-Khan told WNYC. “All of our projects take into account seniors and schoolchildren.”

Yesterday, as kids headed back to class, DOT activated NYC’s first 20 speed cameras in city school zones. Conditions imposed by state lawmakers mean the cameras are operable only from one hour before the school day begins to one hour after it ends, and from 30 minutes before to 30 minutes after school activities. A driver can go up to 10 mph over the speed limit without getting a ticket. Violators will be sent warnings for the first few weeks of the program, after which the fine will be $50 for exceeding the speed limit by 11 mph or more in a school zone where kids are present. DOT hopes to make the most of the cameras by moving them around, and Tri-State Transportation Campaign reports that the expected calming effect may extend beyond school zones.

NYPD will evidently continue to allow motorists to speed through neighborhoods and endanger lives at will. Sadik-Khan says Ray Kelly’s department has no plans to change its enforcement methods now that speed cameras are in place.

  • krstrois

    I moved recently to a residential section of brownstone BK after living for 10+ years in an industrial wasteland/hipster paradise-hell. When I moved to this neighborhood, I noticed that people on the street were warning me to “be careful” whenever I was with my little boy (now 5). Almost every time we reach a crosswalk someone says “be careful” or “be sure you really check.” This is what neighbors do when drivers kill kids regularly and there’s no enforcement and NYPD does not care about neighborhoods, just stats. It’s thoroughly depressing.

  • Parent

    I live in Park Slope. 6 or 7 public schools within blocks of each other. We have more daycare centers and pre-ks than some cities have Starbucks. Drivers routinely speed, fail to yield even to parents pushing strollers, and do whatever they can to beat traffic as they try to make turns. Yet where is the NYPD? Ticketing cyclists on 5th Avenue during the morning commute and handing out red light tickets to bike riders in Prospect Park.

  • Andrew

    NYPD will evidently continue to allow motorists to speed through neighborhoods and endanger lives at will. Sadik-Khan says Ray Kelly’s department has no plans to change its enforcement methods now that speed cameras are in place.

    Because speed enforcement at 20 locations across the five boroughs, at limited hours of the day, only of speeds 10+ mph over the speed limit, with fines of $50 is clearly adequate.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Martin Dilan Introduces 20 MPH Bill in State Senate

|
State Senator Martin Malave Dilan, of Brooklyn, has introduced companion legislation to Assembly Member Dan O’Donnell’s speed limit bill, which would set the maximum speed on NYC streets at 20 miles per hour, except on streets “where the City Council determines a different speed limit is appropriate.” “In the first two weeks of 2014 there were seven […]