Vacca Staffer, Running for Council, Bucks His Boss on Complete Streets

Candidates for the District 15 City Council seat, from left to right: Kenny Agosto, Albert Alvarez, Raquel Batista, Joel Rivera (not the incumbent Joel Rivera -- he's term-limited), Cynthia Thompkins, and Ritchie Torres. Photo: Stephen Miller

In a City Council district in the heart of the Bronx, where the overwhelming majority of households are car-free, an aide to Council Member James Vacca distinguished himself last night by vocally supporting congestion pricing, on-street parking reform, and protected bike lanes.

The District 15 seat, representing Bathgate, Belmont, Crotona, Fordham, East Tremont, Van Nest, and West Farms, is currently held by Joel Rivera, who is term-limited. Candidates Kenny Agosto, Albert Alvarez, Raquel Batista, Joel Rivera (no relation to the incumbent), Cynthia Thompkins, and Ritchie Torres attended the forum, which was sponsored by the Mary Mitchell Family and Youth Center, Bronx Health REACH, and the New York League of Conservation Voters Education Fund.

The forum invitation listed “public transit” as one of the issues up for discussion, but the moderators did not ask any questions related to transportation. In the current district, which was slightly redrawn in the latest round of redistricting, three-quarters of households are car-free, according to the 2000 Census. During the forum, the candidates only mentioned transportation issues tangentially: Alvarez and Torres spoke about the impacts of heavy traffic and idling on asthma, while Agosto said playgrounds at schools should not be used as parking lots.

Streetsblog was able to speak with four of the candidates — Agosto, Alvarez, Thompkins, and Torres — after the event to ask for their positions on bus service and MTA funding.

The district has two Select Bus Service routes, on Fordham Road and Webster Avenue, and all four candidates supported further expansion. “I generally support Select service, but I also don’t want to limit other services,” Agosto said. “We want to make sure that we have adequate service across the board.” Alvarez said he supports further expansion of SBS, as long as the city maintains constant communication with business owners about the potential impact on deliveries. Thompkins said she supports expansion of SBS to Southern Boulevard, which is outside the district, and the Grand Concourse, adding that better bus service can help improve east-west travel within the borough.

When it comes to funding the MTA, however, the candidates weren’t as unanimous.

When Streetsblog asked about congestion pricing or bridge tolls, Agosto was skeptical. “I think if anyone should pay the toll, it should be people from outer communities, from the suburbs. We should bring the commuter tax back,” he said. “We also have to look at their books to see where the money is going.”

“Unless I see a concrete plan for reduction of waste within the MTA, I don’t think we should be taxing our community further,” Alvarez said, adding that any funds generated by the city should not support transit service outside the five boroughs. “Congestion pricing, I know the mayor was big on that before. There’s an argument for it and I think, certain aspects, I would be supportive of.” But when Streetsblog asked which aspects of Bloomberg’s congestion pricing plan had his support, Alvarez, who serves as chief of staff to congestion pricing supporter Joel Rivera, could not name any.

“We’ve got enough tolls, we really do,” Thompkins said, adding that she supports MetroCard vending machines at bus stops and park-and-ride locations to make transit more accessible. “I need my car,” she said. “If I need to go into Manhattan, I don’t have a way that’s easy for me to park and ride.”

But it was Torres who came out the strongest for road pricing. “There should be a market for road space; nobody should be using it for free,” he said. “I would’ve voted for the plan as proposed in 2007. I’d have to review it, but I heard Sam Schwartz has a new iteration.” Vacca, who has fundraised for Torres, voted for congestion pricing but also pressured DOT to keep parking prices low. Torres told Streetsblog that he supports market-based pricing for on-street parking. “I support every initiative that discourages driving,” he said. “I support the complete streets movement.”

“My concern is that too many of the bike lanes amount to paint on the road and there’s no protection for those bike lanes. I mean, I’m too terrified to ride a bike myself,” Torres said, noting that Bronx Park East, Allerton Avenue, and Grand Concourse could be improved for bicycling and walking.

Thompkins, pointing out that hilly topography in the Bronx often leads cyclists to major thoroughfares, also supported protected bike lanes. In addition, she called for more off-peak deliveries and truck route enforcement to keep tractor-trailers off side streets.

“We’ve seen a downward trend in the number of driver’s licenses, in the number of people who are driving, the number of hours and miles being driven. It seems like there’s a cultural shift toward more sustainable modes of transportation,” Torres said, adding that he does not have a driver’s license. “Just at a personal level, I’m not very sensitive to the needs of drivers,” he said with a laugh. “I’m much more sensitive to the needs of pedestrians and bike riders, and transit riders, than I am to motorists.”

Update: In a phone conversation with Streetsblog this afternoon, Raquel Batista said that she supported expanding SBS to the Grand Concourse and Southern Boulevard, as well as improvements to the district’s Metro-North stations, but opposed congestion pricing or tolls to fund the MTA — unless suburbanites were the ones picking up the tab. Batista also singled out the Grand Concourse as a street in need of improved bicyclist and pedestrian safety but did not endorse protected bike lanes when Streetsblog asked about them.

  • Andrew

    ”I need my car,” she said. “If I need to go into Manhattan, I don’t have a way that’s easy for me to park and ride.”

    Hey, voters, does this candidate share your concerns?

  • Bolwerk

    The city should buy these types a one-way ticket to Florida. Use taxpayer money if necessary.

  • Joe R.

    In what alternate universe could it possibly be easier or faster to drive into Manhattan than to take the subway or commuter rail? I can’t believe someone who claims to represent city residents could be this out of touch with reality. Most likely she’s never even been on public transit.

  • Ex-driver

    That quote is a little hard to understand. Does she mean there’s nowhere to park at the train station or bus stop, so she has to drive all the way into town? Is this part of the Bronx that suburban that people need to drive to transit?

  • Andrew

    If she’s not in walking distance of a subway station, she’s probably in walking distance of a bus that will take her to a subway station.

    If she prefers to drive, then she can compete for parking with other motorists like herself. If she’s suggesting that the city buy up and clear out a large plot of land adjacent to the station for her to park on, I would suggest in response that dense residential and/or commercial development is far more valuable at such a location. (But what do I know?)

  • Driver

    In the alternate universe called off-peak hours. There are plenty of times during the day or night that it is faster, sometimes significantly, to drive into Manhattan from eastern Queens, and probably many other parts of the city, than to take mass transit, unless perhaps you live right near a subway or RR line.

  • Shojib Ashrafi Na Ashrafi

    Hello, I was really encouraged to discover this site. The cause getting that this is these kinds of an educational
    put up. I desired to thank you for this insightful read through of the subject.

  • jltomes

    ”I need my car,” she said. “If I need to go into Manhattan, I don’t have a way that’s easy for me to park and ride.” She is out of touch. She avoids taking public transportation (I know personally) for whatever reason, and she does not understand the issues of average new yorkers, especially ones that make less than 40,000 a year (which a large portion of South Bronx make). Elitist poser looking to get her foot into the door of NYC politics. Good luck with that.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

This Week: Bronx Candidate Forum, Safer Amsterdam Avenue

|
The 15th City Council district has seen some notable livable streets changes in the past 6 years, including the addition of two Select Bus Service routes. Will the momentum continue? The candidates to replace term-limited Council Member Joel Rivera square off tonight at a forum about neighborhood health and environmental sustainability. Also this week: Speak […]

Vacca Endorses Move NY Toll Reform as a Fair MTA Funding Fix

|
The Move NY toll reform plan, which would create a consistent toll cordon around the Manhattan central business district while dropping toll rates on outer-borough crossings, has received the endorsement of Council Member James Vacca of the Bronx. “We have to improve mass transit to the central city and we have to discourage car use below 60th Street,” […]