Tonight’s Ride and Forum Are About Livable Streets for All

Mayor John Lindsay (center) and Parks Commissioner August Hecksher (in white shirt) lead ride up Sixth Ave. to Central Park, April 1, 1968.

New York City bicyclists will celebrate bike activism’s past, present and future this evening in a ride from Greenwich Village to Central Park South and back to the Village, culminating in a community forum at Cooper Union. These linked happenings come the day after the New York Times managed to twist its big story on the July 2011-June 2012 spike in NYC traffic fatalities into a jab at DOT Commissioner Janette Sadik-Khan’s livable streets makeover.

Sadly, the connections between the fatalities story and tonight’s events aren’t just in the timing.

The most obvious connection, and the most painful, is that the Houston Street and Sixth Avenue meetup for tonight’s ride, which was chosen months ago, is where long-time Village resident Jessica Dworkin was run over in late August when the driver of an 18-wheeler steered his rig into her.

There’s a more enduring connection as well, and it’s two-fold: first, there’s the media’s chronic inability to scrutinize traffic-crash data critically to determine, as we at Transportation Alternatives asked a quarter-of-a-century ago, Who’s Really Getting Hurt?; paired with that is the NYPD’s utter unconcern about traffic safety and justice — from its autopilot “No Criminality” statements that appear even before the blood has been washed off the pavement, to its blanket refusals to release crash analyses by its Accident Investigation Squad.

Streetsblog has run dozens of posts on NYPD stonewalling, so let’s focus here on how the Times mis-reported the jump in fatalities.

The raw figures are simple enough: from the 2011 fiscal year ending June 30, 2011, to the 2012 fiscal year ending June 30, 2012:

  • Motor vehicle occupant fatalities rose by 37, from 78 to 115, a jump of 47 percent.
  • Non-occupant (pedestrian and cyclist) fatalities rose by 18, from 158 to 176, an increase of 11 percent.
  • Total traffic fatalities rose by 55, from 236 to 291, an increase of 23 percent.

The takeaways are fairly obvious too:

  • Driving, walking and cycling in New York City were less safe in FY 2012 than in FY 2011.
  • The increase in danger was concentrated in driving, with an increase in fatalities twice as large as that for walking and cycling — and four times as great in percentage terms.

How, then, did the Times story manage to center its lead on DOT’s “roadway interventions,” virtually all of which have been on streets, not highways?

For years, the New York City Transportation Department has held a trump card in the roiling debate over its many roadway interventions: When officials said the measures, like pedestrian plazas and bike lanes, had made streets safer, the numbers appeared to back them up. But the release last week of the Mayor’s Management Report [large PDF, the data are at p. 134], a twice-yearly collection of city measures, revealed a disquieting figure. Traffic fatalities from July 2011 through June 2012 were up 23 percent from the previous year — to 291, from 236. It was the first increase since 2007, when there were 310 traffic fatalities.

One could just as easily twist the same data and conclude that the DOT’s livable streets initiatives saved more than 50 lives last year: after all, if walker and bicyclist fatalities had risen as sharply as deaths for vehicle occupants, the increased bike-ped toll would have been 74 rather than the actual 18. (That’s ‘cause 47 percent of 158 is 74.)

Such an inference would be speculative if not downright nutty, of course, but no more so than the Times’ insinuation that bike lanes, pedestrian plazas and such had anything to do with the alarming rise in citywide traffic fatalities over the past 12 months.

We don’t know precisely what caused traffic deaths to spike. We don’t even know where — in which boroughs, in which precincts, how many on highways vs. how many on streets — the increases were concentrated. But we do know that the combination of motor vehicles’ bulk and speeds, drivers’ sense of aggrievement and entitlement, and NYPD and prosecutors’ indifference, has and will always spell tragedy and death.

Tonight’s ride and forum are focused on bike activism, but bike advocacy has always been about more than cycling alone. We seek, as NYC bicycle designer and visionary George Bliss wrote several decades ago, a democratic joining of mobility and community that provides safe travel for all. It is fitting that the ride begins at the site of an all-too-recent and horrific pedestrian death, and that the forum that follows is at the Cooper Union Great Hall, a true cradle of citizenship. Tonight’s events are free. I hope to see you at both.

  • Albert

    And before or after tonight’s forum, please take a minute to stop by the TA table and write a personal note to Mayor Bloomberg asking for protected bicycle lanes and pedestrian safety amenities on 5th & 6th Avenues—TA’s new campaign for safer streets.

  • Albert

    And before or after tonight’s forum, please take a minute to stop by the TA table and write a personal note to Mayor Bloomberg asking for protected bicycle lanes and pedestrian safety amenities on 5th & 6th Avenues—TA’s new campaign for safer streets.

  • Albert

    And before or after tonight’s forum, please take a minute to stop by the TA table and write a personal note to Mayor Bloomberg asking for protected bicycle lanes and pedestrian safety amenities on 5th & 6th Avenues—TA’s new campaign for safer streets.

  • Steve Faust

    Summer 1980 the New York Times published a series of Killer Bike articles and editorials. This may have been written before, but 1980 is the earliest direct Times attack on bicyclists that I remember.

    For 32 years the Times has been confusing bicyclists with drivers as the cause of traffic deaths.  Why should they break this track record now and present the facts as they are, and not as they wish them to be.

  • Wow, can’t imagine TA doing anything edgy or contesting the mayor on a large scale ever nowadays, just shilling for him, guess it is the $…

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

This Week in Livable Streets Events

|
The main event for the week has to be the Bicycle Film Festival, which starts Wednesday. But there’s plenty more happening on the Streetsblog Calendar. Here’s a sampling. Monday: Five Borough Bicycle Club June Meeting: Nassau County Prosecutor’s DWI Crackdown. In light of the interest in holding drivers accountable for their actions, tonight’s 5BBC general […]

This Week in Livable Streets Events

|
It looks like we have a pretty quiet week coming up. For those who have reserved their seats (registration is closed), tonight’s "Hacking the City" session, featuring Aaron Naparstek and others from The Open Planning Project, starts at 6:30. Otherwise, most of the noteworthy events come toward the tail end of the week.  Friday: Free […]

Streetsblog Interview: Ryan Russo

|
Ryan Russo is the New York City Department of Transportation’s Director for Street Management and Safety, a newly-created job that he started in July. Previously, Russo worked as DOT’s Downtown Brooklyn Transportation Coordinator where he was instrumental in designing and developing a number of improvements for pedestrians, cyclists and more livable streets (PDF file) over the last three years. Streetsblog caught up […]

Share Your Outreach Strategies

|
Cantor Benjamin Kintisch When starting a new Livable Streets campaign people will often ask us, "How do I connect with others in my neighborhood and build a working group?" Cantor Benjamin Kintisch is facing this familiar concern in Harlem and Hamilton Heights, and this time we’re putting the question to you. If you’ve had success […]