Park Avenue Plan Challenges Agencies to Improve Street for Pedestrians

In 1959, when the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway was under construction, Park Avenue in the Wallabout section of Fort Greene and Clinton Hill was converted from a neighborhood street to a service road that would run underneath the new elevated highway. Walking on the street hasn’t been the same since. With 160,000 cars roaring by overhead each day, two lanes in each direction on the surface, and more than 300 parking spaces in the median, the street is not what you would call pedestrian-friendly. It’s also dangerous, with a crash rate higher than three-quarters of Brooklyn streets.

“The Crossover,” where the BQE and Park Avenue part ways, currently functions like a highway merge on surface streets (top). Under a new, community-backed proposal, this location would see major changes to curb speeding and make crossings safer (bottom). Image: MARP/Architecture for Humanity

More than 50 years after Robert Moses and the BQE changed Park Avenue, the Myrtle Avenue Revitalization Project Local Development Corporation (MARP) is pushing to enhance the street for walking and public activity, unveiling a slate of proposals to reduce speeding and improve pedestrian safety [PDF].

In 2009 and 2010, MARP hosted three community workshops as part of an effort to reuse spaces beneath the BQE. Based on community feedback at those events, the group decided to focus on traffic safety. In late 2010, Architecture for Humanity New York joined the project, working with MARP throughout 2011 to conduct research and host workshops. An advisory committee comprised of residents, community organizations and city agencies also helped guide the recommendations. Funding for the report was provided by the Brooklyn Community Foundation.

The recommendations are comprehensive and address everything from litter to traffic signal timing. In May, MARP went before Community Board 2’s transportation committee, which voted unanimously to support the proposals.

Intersections would receive significant upgrades. The plan calls for neckdowns and crosswalk markings on cross-streets along the median. Access points to parking underneath the BQE would be marked as pedestrian crossings, with raised crosswalks and stop signs. At North Portland, Clinton and Clermont Avenues, the report recommends closing auto access to parking under the BQE to improve safety for the higher number of pedestrians crossing Park Avenue at those intersections.

Perhaps the knottiest location is at the eastern end of the corridor at “the Crossover,” where the BQE bends north and westbound Park Avenue curves beneath the expressway. The absence of crosswalks and the highway ramp-like design of this location encourage speeding and make crossing difficult. In 2010, cyclist Stefanos Tsigrimanis was killed by a driver at this location. MARP’s proposal would eliminate the crossover, directing westbound traffic on Park Avenue to cross under the BQE at Grand Avenue. This creates a large space underneath the BQE that could be used for community events or parking.

Traffic volumes on Park are low enough, the report says, to justify converting one of the two lanes in each direction to parallel parking outside of rush hour. Currently, parking is only allowed on the outside lanes of the corridor, but not along the median. Median-side parking would reduce speeding when traffic volumes are low. It is also less expensive than curb extensions and could be implemented almost immediately.

Typical intersection improvements include curb extensions and new crosswalks. Image: MARP/Architecture for Humanity

Additionally, the report recommends adding street trees to reduce speeding and provide greenery, daylighting intersections by removing parking (which would improve visibility for drivers and pedestrians), and adding bus bulbs for the four busiest bus stops on Park Avenue: eastbound at Carlton Avenue and westbound at Washington Avenue, Carlton Avenue and North Portland Street.

The report calls on NYPD to increase speeding enforcement, especially during hours with the highest pedestrian volumes. The 88th Precinct, which covers the entire Park Avenue study area, issued 29 speeding tickets in 2012 as of July. More than three times as many tickets were issued for tinted windows. In all of 2011, the precinct issued 42 speeding tickets. That’s less than one a week.

Stormwater management is also a concern along the corridor. MARP is asking the New York State DOT to fix leaky drainage pipes from the BQE. Where the sidewalk is too narrow for street trees, the report proposes tree bump-outs that can handle stormwater runoff from the street. MARP has also partnered with planning and engineering firm AKRF on preliminary designs for a planter near Steuben Street that would collect runoff from the BQE drainage pipes.

“We’ve been communicating with various agencies throughout the process,” said MARP Deputy Director Meredith Phillips Almeida in a statement, “but it is important that we continue to show there is broad-based community support for making these improvements as soon as possible.”

MARP is presenting the plan at an event this afternoon featuring Transportation Alternatives, Council Member Letitia James and State Committee Member Lincoln Restler. Stay tuned for more coverage.

  • Jeff

    Can we get some help over on Meeker Ave, too?  I’m especially bothered by pedestrian-hostile, highway-like conditions on highway service roads because, well, we built them a friggin’ highway!!!  That’s right:  There is an unsightly great-wall-of-china tearing through the heart of my neighborhood, but apparently that’s not enough.  Apparently they have to make asses of themselves on the service road, too (And not to mention that the area underneath of this massive, ungodly monument to automobility, sandwiched between the automobile-centric service road, is reserved for none other than–you guessed it–automobile storage!).

  • Alan

    This would be awesome. Crossing under the BQE, which is necessary for connecting from the Kent/Flushing bikeway to the rest of Brooklyn is a huge mess on a bike. I just ran into that terrifying Park Ave. crossover by accident while attempting to get under the freeway on Grand. Hopefully they open the side streets back up for bicycling; right now Vanderbilt (which is relatively heavily used) seems like the best choice for a north-south route.

  • Ari

    If you want to see this plan implemented, please sign the online petition:
    http://www.change.org/petitions/make-brooklyn-s-park-avenue-safer-for-pedestrians

  • Robert Perris

    Since the recommendations are still schematic, it would be more accurate to say that the transportation committee of Community Board 2 voted to support the scope of the proposals.  The community board’s executive committee ratified that recommendation, with both actions occurring in June, not May.  Specific proposals will be reviewed by the board int he future.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Brooklyn CB 2 Committee Unanimously Backs Park Avenue Safety Fixes

|
Last night, Brooklyn Community Board 2’s transportation committee unanimously supported a set of traffic calming measures on Park Avenue in Clinton Hill and Fort Greene, including a road diet for eastbound traffic [PDF]. The proposal from DOT comes after years of advocacy from local residents and organizations fed up with speeding and dangerous conditions on […]

Rezoning to Encourage Street Life on Brooklyn’s Fourth Avenue

|
When the Department of City Planning put forward its rezoning of Park Slope in 2003, one of the earliest of the now 111 rezonings under Mayor Bloomberg and City Planning Commissioner Amanda Burden, it was intended to help turn Fourth Avenue into “a grand boulevard of the 21st Century.” The sought-after residential development has started […]

Brooklyn to Bloomberg: Include Local Stakeholders in Planning

|
Below is a letter from the Park Slope Civic Council to Mayor Bloomberg and local elected representatives regarding the City’s plan to transform Sixth and Seventh Avenue’s into one-way streets. It’s lengthy but it’s worth a read (and full disclosure: I’m a trustee of the Civic Council): Park Slope Civic Council March 7, 2007 Dear […]

Brooklyn CB 2 Committee Says Yes to Lafayette Avenue Shared Lane

|
Last night, Brooklyn Community Board 2’s Transportation and Public Safety Committee voted 8 to 1 (with one abstention) to support DOT’s proposal to install sharrows on Lafayette Avenue between Fulton Street and Classon Avenue. The vote comes after DOT abandoned a bike lane concept in 2010, spurring neighborhood residents to gather 1,400 signatures seeking a […]