New York’s Car Ownership Rate Is on The Rise


Car-free households broken down by Assembly district. Red areas indicate where car ownership has gone up, blue areas where it has decreased. Click on each district for more information.

Fewer New Yorkers are driving to work than they did a decade ago, according to Census data Streetsblog reported on last December. But that same data shows that the citywide car ownership rate increased by 1.7 percentage points over the same period.

Among all NYC households, 46 percent own cars, according to Census data gathered between 2005 and 2009, compared to 44.3 percent in 2000. Factoring in Census data on the number of cars each household owns, that adds up to about 120,000 more cars in New York City.

We put together a spreadsheet (which you can download here) comparing new Census data on car ownership to information from the 2000 Census. (The main dataset in the spreadsheet is the percentage of car-free households in each legislative district, so negative changes are actually increases in the car ownership rate.)

The growth in car ownership was spread across the state, with increases in 126 out of 150 Assembly districts. Altogether, the statewide car ownership rate rose by about 1.4 percentage points, slightly less than in New York City.

The Bronx saw the most notable upticks in car ownership. Four of the five Assembly districts with the largest increases in car ownership rates were in that borough: AD 85 (Marcus Crespo, Soundview), AD 86 (Nelson Castro, Fordham), AD 77 (Vanessa Gibson, Morris Heights), and AD 84 (Carmen Arroyo, Mott Haven). All of those districts started from a relatively low baseline of car ownership. In AD 85, which saw the biggest jump, for instance, car ownership rose from 29.1 percent to 35.8 percent.

Of the few districts that saw their car ownership rate fall, the top five were AD 49 (Peter Abbate, Bensonhurst), AD 22 (Grace Meng, Flushing), AD 95 (Ellen Jaffee, Rockland County), AD 66 (Deborah Glick, Greenwich Village), and AD 67 (Linda Rosenthal, Upper West Side). The biggest change happened in AD 49, where the car ownership rate fell by 2.4 percentage points.

Interestingly, the only two New York City districts where our previous analysis found that the percentage of people driving to work increased since 2000, Glick’s and Richard Gottfried’s, both saw their car ownership rates go down.

It’s notable that the share of New Yorkers who own cars rose while the share of those who commuted by car fell. Given that higher car ownership should lead to more driving, all things being equal, this suggests that factors like traffic congestion or high gas prices made driving to work less attractive even for people who own cars.

Transportation analyst Charles Komanoff pointed to the fact that car ownership only increased in owner-occupied housing units, not rentals, and that more households owned their own homes in the recent Census. He hypothesized that something connected to the increase in home ownership, such as a larger affluent population, was propelling the increase in car ownership.

The higher car ownership rate also has important implications for parking policy. With the city’s population on the rise and the share who own cars also increasing, there are many more cars in need of storage than a decade ago. The increasingly desperate attempts to squeeze more on-street parking spaces out of the city’s fixed supply of curb space may make more sense in the light of those numbers, for example. The increased car ownership rate could also reflect the Bloomberg administration’s policy of enabling large amounts of off-street parking to be built throughout the city (though the Department of City Planning would probably cite rising car ownership to justify that same policy).

Map compiled by Frank Hebbert/OpenPlans.

  • It doesn’t help very much to note that car ownership in New York City is increasing without comparing it to the increase in rate of ownership of other durable goods, like boats, bicycles, helicopters, exercise equipment, and furniture.

  • Thanks for the clarification, Clarence. I probably should have qualified my statement with the term “new car”, although owning even an old car isn’t cheap in this city. As far as I know, just liability insurance alone for a 10-year old car costs around what subway fare does for a year. But point taken-time is money. If the situation is really as lopsided as you say, with 15-20 minutes by ca versus 90 by public tranist,. then any additional expene makes sense. My brother ironically is in the same boat, commuting from the Rockaways to Flushing. By car it’s anywhere from 30 minutes to over an hour with traffic. Best case by public transit might be close to 2 hours. He goes 15 miles each way, so biking really isn’t an option, either.

    Both these situations (your wife. my brother) point to the need for NYC to build better mass transit for intraborough commuting. We certainly have the population density to justify it but apparently not the political will. Bikes can take up some commuting load also, but without major changes in both infrastructure/equipment, I can’t see bike commutes of more than 10 miles being viable for large numbers of people.

  • Clarence

    Of course the craziest thing of all: tonight on my 50 pound Dutch bike I rode from Jackson Heights to Carroll Gardens for a party and back. That’s a 22 mile round trip. I did it mostly because – believe it or not – it is the fastest trip – about an hour by bike, a smidgen longer with subway/walk. I get exercise and save $4.50 and have full control over where I go.

    We do need better choices. It does not make sense the way some of our transit options are set up.

  • ajedrez

    But the percentage of people who own a car has increased. As the population increases, the number of car-owners should increase, but the percentage of car-owners should decrease.

  • ajedrez

    I noticed that my area has seen a 1.7% increase in auto-ownership, even as transportation options have increased. We received a bus to Bayonne (the S89), and expanded service on the express bus routes to Manhattan. I don’t see what could be causing the increase. I would think that, instead of going from 14.3% to 12.6%, out autoless rate would’ve increased to around 18-20% from 2000.

    The only thing I can think of is that the Census Bureau happened to pick the wrong sample when calcluating autoless households, at least over here.

  • Your point is exactly why we need to compare car ownership rates with rates of ownership of other durable goods. That 2% increase could just be the result of a couple of families buying their kids cars for high-school graduation because they had a good year and were feeling flush.

  • @jrab — it doesn’t seem likely to me that a car-free household would buy its first car for a teenager. (But I get your point.)

  • Ayh127

    If you live in NYC you should try a Bumpshox.  It’s small, unobtrusive, and will not detract from the look of your car. 

  • Look for a cheap used car, find it on http://www.kofys.com

  • Finally, someone who gets it!

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

How Bike Corrals Expand New Yorkers’ Access to Businesses

|
A quick note about the new bike corral on Franklin Avenue in Crown Heights, which got a vote of approval from the local community board after hundreds of signatures were gathered in support of it. The Prospect Heights Patch reports that two local residents see the on-street bike parking as a symbol of gentrification and […]

Opposing the Move NY Plan Does No Favors for Southeast Queens

|
Four highways encircle New York’s 27th City Council district, a largely African-American section of southeast Queens: the Grand Central Parkway on the north, the Van Wyck Expressway on the west, the Southern State Parkway on the south, and the Cross Island Parkway on the east. Highways girdle the transportation perspective of the 27th District’s Council […]
STREETSBLOG USA

Low-Income Americans Walk and Bike to Work the Most

|
The U.S. Census Bureau just released its first-ever report exclusively on walking and biking. Using data from the American Community Survey, the report shows how rates of active transportation vary by age, income, education, race, and the availability of a vehicle. It’s a lot more detail than the usual Census data release on how people get […]