DOT Adds Delivery Zones to Tackle Church Avenue Double Parking

During the morning, trucks would have dedicated loading zones along much of this Church Avenue strip in order to reduce double-parking.
To reduce double-parking, DOT is adding dedicated loading zones in the morning along much of this Church Avenue strip. Image: NYC DOT

The fight for scarce street space is always fierce in New York City, and as DOT’s efforts to install bike and bus lanes across the city have revealed, the most contested zone of all is probably the curbside. On commercial streets, drivers can’t get enough of the underpriced on-street parking while businesses want curbside access to load and unload deliveries. The result is rampant double-parking, cruising, and ultimately congestion — slowing down buses and creating more dangerous conditions for pedestrians and cyclists. In some cases, local displeasure about curbside dysfunction manifests itself as opposition to seemingly unrelated livable streets improvements, like the Fifth Avenue bike lane in Park Slope.

Image: NYC DOT.
Image: NYC DOT

With a new program on Brooklyn’s Church Avenue, DOT is trying to solve at least one part of the puzzle. Starting in mid-January, 40 parking spaces on Church Avenue will be dedicated exclusively for deliveries from 7 a.m. to noon on weekdays. On the block between 18th and 19th Streets, truck loading will be available until 3:00 p.m.

With 65 percent of all deliveries to the neighborhood already taking place before noon, according to DOT, the idea is to give trucks the space they need at times when they’re just going to take it anyway. If successful, all the area’s deliveries could be made in the dedicated spaces within the time window. Theoretically, no trucks would double-park, morning or afternoon.

One group that should be particularly excited: the 38,000 weekday riders on the B35 bus, the sixth busiest route in the city. They’re paying the price for the fact that at least one Church Avenue lane — and there’s only one in each direction — is blocked by double-parkers for a quarter of the day, according to DOT.

The program has strong backing from local businesses. According to Community Board 14 chair Alvin Berk, a few years ago, the Church Avenue BID came to the community board with a proposal to bring ParkSmart to the stretch, raising meter rates during peak demand hours. “At the time, its utility hadn’t been demonstrated,” said Berk (the program has since been shown to cut traffic and increase the number of cars that are able to park), so the board proposed an alternative.

First, two-hour metered spaces were reduced to one-hour, with the intention of increasing turnover. The new delivery zones are the final part of that plan. “We’re very optimistic about it,” said Berk, who added that ParkSmart could be back on the table if this program doesn’t show results after a year or so. The BID has also endorsed the plan.

  • kevd

    That stretch of Church is a complete mess with double parkers.
    All those spaces might actually be enough to help the problem.

    Caton’s also a mess. How you gonna fix that, DOT?

  • dporpentine

    Sounds like a very sensible solution.

    And since it’s an area that mostly serves many fewer well-heeled people than Fifth Avenue in Park Slope or PPW, we’ll probably never hear another word about it.

    Things done in poor neighborhoods aren’t controversial!

  • kevd

    And, there are no former deputy mayors or former DOT heads / senator’s wives in Flatbush to mess it up.

  • It seems to me that there should be loading zones everywhere, at least one space on every block and many more in dense commercial areas. Otherwise trucks block bike lanes, bus stops, hydrants, sidewalks, and wherever else they feel like parking. Here in Boston the delivery drivers I’ve spoken to said they simply view parking tickets as a cost of doing business. So if we ever want to regain control of our infrastructure, loading zones is a good place to start, but more effective enforcement against violations by delivery vehicles must be included.

  • Why not implement these new loading zones and ParkSmart?


Fifth Ave BID, CB6 District Manager Take Aim at Park Slope Bike Lane

Fifth Avenue in Park Slope on a weekday morning. What’s wrong with this picture? Photo: Ben Fried. Just about every New York City neighborhood has to deal with the consequences of dirt cheap on-street parking. When you practically give away spaces at rock-bottom prices, it guarantees double parking and endless cruising for spots by bargain […]

CB 4 Wants On-Street Bike Parking for Ninth Avenue

CHEKPEDS reports that Community Board 4 voted last week for the creation of on-street parking spots for bikes along Ninth Avenue: DOT had sent the board a list of bike racks to install on our sidewalks. After an extensive review, it became apparent that in many locations there is not enough space to accommodate both […]

Whose Parking Regime Reigns Supreme? LA, SF, and NYC Compare Notes

Less than a week after Queens Community Board 3 signed off on DOT’s PARK Smart pilot for Jackson Heights, New York’s neighborhood-level parking policy changes were given some national context on Wednesday at the National Association of City Transportation Officials’ “Designing Cities” conference. Given the Department of City Planning’s halfhearted attempts to reduce off-street parking requirements, NYC […]

Eyes on the Street: Third Avenue Bus Island Nears Completion

Pedestrians and bus riders at one of the most dangerous intersections in Midtown now have a bit more breathing room. Work on a block-long pedestrian island on Third Avenue is complete, providing space for pedestrians between drivers turning right onto 57th Street and traffic heading uptown. It also includes a new bus stop and shelter [PDF]. The intersection, crammed with […]