Vacca and Advocates to Albany: No More Transit Raids

Transit advocates and City Council transportation committee chair Jimmy Vacca are sounding the alarm about potential transit funding raids before the year is out. A $315 million hole has opened up in the state budget, and unless elected officials change the way they balance the state’s books, straphangers could end up paying for Albany’s fiscal mess — again.

It could happen again. Graphic:
Albany transit raids will keep on happening until elected officials change the way they balance the state's books. Graphic: Carly Clark/Streetsblog

Last December, Albany swiped $143 million in MTA funding — most of which came from dedicated transit taxes — to cover the state’s budget gap. That funding would have been enough to prevent all the subway and bus cuts that the MTA enacted this year. More recently, Albany took $16.7 million in dedicated transit tax revenue to make up for a shortfall in federal Medicaid assistance.

Now the state is looking at a midyear budget deficit of $315 million. Vacca, NYPIRG’s Straphangers Campaign, Transportation Alternatives, and the Tri-State Transportation Campaign sent a letter today to Governor Paterson, Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver and State Senate leader John Sampson warning against another transit raid. It concludes:

Straphangers face the real possibility of additional service cuts or fare hikes if the MTA cannot identify steady funding sources. At a time when the State should be focused on shoring up the future of mass transit funding — and restoring the $143 million that was diverted last year — conducting another ‘sweep’ would send a terrible message.

Denying the MTA any additional funds from its dedicated tax stream at this time would be a short-term fix with severe long-term consequences. We urge you to take a different route.

The state’s repeated looting of dedicated MTA revenues is a problem that Albany may have to address before incoming governor Andrew Cuomo assumes office. And it will still rear its head after Cuomo becomes governor.

Streetsblog will be taking a closer look at what Cuomo, Sheldon Silver’s Assembly, and the State Senate (likely under the leadership of Long Island Republican Dean Skelos) can do to protect straphangers and preserve the integrity of the MTA’s funding streams. Stay tuned.

  • Cant NY pass a proposition like the one that just passed in California? The people voting to make it illegal for the state to raid transportation funds.

  • Joby

    Jass,
    Such a change is necessary given what has transpired time and again in NY. In NY we don’t have direct to voter propositions like CA. According to Lexis Nexis there are two methods to amend the NYS Constitution: (1) by Constitutional Convention or (2) by having the amendment approved twice by the NY State legislature and approved by a general election.
    If we can get a serious enough campaign around that we might be able to force the legislature to put such a measure to the voters. I suspect voters would approve the measure.

  • You know, I hadnt realized that prop 22 would amend the constitution, I thought it was just a statute. But yes, 61% of California voters approved it.

    New yorkers need to do something fast

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Can Andrew Cuomo Stop Albany From Raiding Transit Again?

|
Yesterday, City Council transportation committee chair Jimmy Vacca and leading transportation advocates sent a letter to New York state’s current leadership urging them not to raid the MTA’s dedicated funds to close an impending $315 million budget deficit. As long as the MTA’s finances are vulnerable to Albany incursions, transit riders will be at risk. […]

Advocates and Unions to Cuomo: Put a Stop to Transit Raids

|
A broad coalition of good government groups, transit and environmental advocates, and unions sent a letter to Andrew Cuomo on Friday [PDF] urging the incoming governor to protect straphangers by ensuring that transit revenues are spent on transit. In the last year, Albany raids have shortchanged the MTA of more than $160 million, deepening a […]

Cuomo on MTA Raids: Transit Funds Are “Fungible”

|
WNYC’s Andrea Bernstein reports on the most troubling sign yet that Governor-elect Andrew Cuomo is not willing to stop Albany’s practice of raiding dedicated transit funds to plug gaps in the state budget. From a press conference yesterday: Cuomo: “I understand the concern. Everyone — especially in a declining budget environment, where we are now, […]

Will Cuomo Sign the Transit Lockbox Bill?

|
The transit lockbox bill, which would require Albany to disclose the impacts of any raid of dedicated transit funds, passed both the Senate and Assembly unanimously in the final days of the legislative session, reports the Tri-State Transportation Campaign. It now heads to Governor Andrew Cuomo’s desk. A nearly identical bill reached Cuomo in 2011, […]