The Importance of Mobility for the World’s Women

Today on the Streetsblog Network, some thoughts on women and transportation coming out of the current annual meeting of the Clinton Global Initiative, courtesy of The City Fix. Writing about yesterday’s panel discussion on investing in the well-being of women and girls, Erica Schlaikjer says:

2256838279_181975031a.jpgMuch depends on her ability to move about freely. Photo by clara & james via Flickr.

Although not explicitly stated in the panel, gender inequality permeates the transportation world. The problems female transit users
face in cities around the world may not be entirely equivalent to the
global atrocities of war, rape, or torture, but there are numerous
studies that show women’s fear of victimization in transportation settings, like bus stops,
and other public spaces. Also, transport policies often marginalize or
ignore women, who have different travel patterns and behaviors than men
but do not have access to adequate transit routes. And gender workforce
segregation in the transit industry has also shown to be a detrimental
factor to a city’s economy…

The problem is, no matter where in the world, "the present transport
system has largely been constructed for men by men," according to a
working paper, “Promoting gender equality in transport,”
published by the Equal Opportunities Commission in the U.K. This means
transport policies do not always consider the differing travel needs of
women vs. men.

For example, "roads for motorized transport often do not benefit
rural women, who mainly work in and around the village and travel on
foot," the World Bank states in its "Transport and Gender Equality"
briefing note. "Urban Transport Systems that transport people to and
from employment centers are sometimes inadequate for women, who must
combine income-generating activities with household and familial
activities, such as taking children to school and health centers and
visiting the market."

Changing transportation infrastructure to benefit both sexes isn’t
just about getting people from Point A to Point B, though. The World
Bank emphasizes that "gender-responsive infrastructure interventions"
also trickle down to other things: "[they] can free up women’s time,
thereby increasing girls enrollment in schools and facilitating women’s
participation in income-generation and decision-making activities."

As Treehugger recently pointed out, women’s mobility via bike (and sometimes car) is actually prohibited in certain places: Saudi Arabia (where women are also banned from driving); North Korea; and in many cases in Iran.

And in other places, the ability of women to ride transit is severely compromised by rampant sexual assault and harassment. The City Fix points out a recent article in the New York Times on the institution of "Ladies Specials" in India — a necessary innovation so that working women can ride the train without fear of harassment. In Mexico City, "women-only" buses were instituted last year to fight the problem there. In Japan, where at least a hundred websites give "how-to" advice to would-be transit gropers, police just launched a crackdown on the sexual assailants who notoriously roam that country’s transit systems.

All of these initiatives are limited in scope and leave the situation of many women unaddressed.

(Here in the U.S., the response has been more grass-roots. Sites like Holla Back NYC and Holla Back DC are giving women a place to document harassment on transit and on the streets and tools to organize against it.)

All of this is a sobering reminder that for many women around the world, the simple right to go freely and fearlessly about their daily business remains compromised. How are we as a planet ever going to get anywhere as long as that remains the case?

Bonus: At Streetsblog Network member World Streets, Eric Britton has issued a call to make 2009 "The Year of the Woman" in transportation.

  • All of this is a sobering reminder that for many women around the world, the simple right to go freely and fearlessly about their daily business remains compromised. How are we as a planet ever going to get anywhere as long as that remains the case?

    Great argument for automobilism and automobiles. I can’t wait until GM’s ad agency gets wind of this one.

  • Karin

    Except that women do not always feel safe in automobiles either. Walking to the last parking space at shopping center in the evening hours can spur the same fears as waiting at a bus stop.

  • Erin

    In places like the US, women spend much more time in automobiles than men, primarily because they must drive so far between work, home, their child’s school, their child’s sports practice, the grocery store, the mall, etc. Single use zoning has put a strain on women that most men don’t fully appreciate. Transit routes, especially suburban transit routes, prioritize commute trips (home to work and back) and are not responsive to the travel patterns of women.

    More dense, mixed-use development can free women of the travel time in cars and also alow children to transport themselves by biking, walking, and taking transit. Most suburban moms, and dads who act as primary care givers, can tell you how much they dread being trapped inside the car as a chauffer. Maybe mom’s free time could be a selling point for Safe Routes to School?

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

STREETSBLOG USA

Women in Transit: Still Swimming Upstream

|
Transportation planning and policy has traditionally been a very male dominated field — and that continues to be reflected in policy. State DOTs, generally speaking, are crowded with white, male engineers whose training is in building highways. Perhaps the inevitable result is that the issues facing a mother trying to load her stroller onto a […]
STREETSBLOG USA

Focusing Only on Commutes Overlooks Women’s Transportation Needs

|
Commuting accounts for only about 15 percent of trips in the United States. But when planners make transportation infrastructure decisions, they often base them on commuting patterns, not other types of trips. One side effect of this convention is that it undervalues trips by women, writes U.K. blogger Katja Leyendecker, and contributes to a built environment that is poorly suited to women’s needs. She […]
STREETSBLOG USA

Census: American Bike Commuting Up Nine Percent in 2012

|
Congratulations, America. We’re biking to work more than ever before. We’ve known for a while that Americans are driving less than they used to, even as the economy grows. And just about every quarter, the American Public Transportation Association delivers more stats about increasing transit ridership. Now the Census brings another measure of Americans’ shifting transportation […]