In Dallas, You Don’t Get What You Don’t Pay For

On Monday, we featured a post from The Transit Pass that called out Dallas as one of the U.S. cities in which the proportion of transit users to population is sadly anemic.

Today, we’ll take a closer look at transit in the Dallas area, from a couple of angles.

299451235_a0b9918346.jpgThe DART light rail system in Dallas is experiencing growing pains. Photo by K_Gradinger via Flickr.

First, courtesy of the Dallas Transportation Blog at the Dallas Morning News, a report on passenger frustration with delays on the city’s newest light rail route, the DART Green Line. Those delays are causing ripple effects throughout the city’s transit system, and it’s not clear when they will be resolved. Stories in the paper about the delays have gotten a lot of comments from readers angry that the problems were not better anticipated and planned for.

But reporter Michael Lindenberger says the city’s voters need to take some responsibility for the way the system is developing:

The general tone of many of the comments has been dismissive, along
the lines of, Idiots! How could DART not build a system that could
avoid the kinds of problems we’ve encountered this week.…

Some have recalled former City Council member Max Goldblatt’s campaign
to build an elevated monorail, rather than at-grade light rail lines.…

But … voters
here rejected a plan by DART to borrow $1 billion to fast-track the
development of DART.

Maybe an elevated monorail would have made sense — or maybe not. But it would have been a lot more expensive. And who was going to pay for these underground or elevated systems? If you wanna sing the blues, you know it don’t come easy — and transit systems (or highways for that matter) don’t come free.…

You could argue that…DART should have moved
faster, and should have built a more innovative system to avoid pesky
things like downtown crossings. But you can’t argue that, unless you’re
willing to also argue that it should have spent more money.

And that money, friends, is our money. I think that’s worth thinking
about. DART is trying to build the best system we can afford.

Meanwhile, Streetsblog Network member blog Trains for America highlights another story from the Dallas Morning News (also written by Lindenberger), this one about the utter lack of public transportation options to reach the new Dallas Cowboys stadium in Arlington, Texas — "America’s largest city without a single bus line or passenger rail line."

That might be a problem, considering that the Cowboys only control about 12,000 parking spots at the stadium, with 12,000 more around the not-so-nearby Texas Rangers ballpark — and 100,000 fans are expected to attend a typical game. Once they get there, parking will be mighty expensive, up to $75 per game for the choice stadium lots that are reserved for season ticket holders. Check out the reams of instructions on the Cowboys site. 

But the situation is, once again, the local voters’ choice, writes Lindenberger:

The lack of
transit options in Arlington, population 365,000, is deliberate — and
comes despite the best efforts of city leaders and regional planners.

Voters in the past three decades have rejected three initiatives that
would have dedicated sales taxes to transit, including twice since
2002.

"They don’t want it," said former Arlington Mayor
Elzie Odom, who retired as mayor in 2003. "It doesn’t do any good to
argue. We have done that three times. The residents who bother to go to
the polls just won’t have it."

Voters did approve the new
stadium, which cost $1.1 billion and was paid for in part by a
half-cent sales tax increase. Even the new stadium, and the traffic
troubles that come with it, haven’t persuaded voters to think again
about transit, he said.

"In the last two elections, I
have heard over and over, "We don’t want those kinds of people.’ People
say they just want to be let alone."

"Let alone" — with the crush of traffic that Cowboys games are sure to bring. Trains for America calls it "a mirror into the soul" of the community. What that mirror shows looks like a lot of tailpipe fumes.

  • Mononuttery

    Monorail = Flying cars = Nutjobbery

  • Arlington sounds more like the “mirror into the soul” is revealing its racism and the stigma of public transportation. Somewhat more sinister than tailpipe fumes.

  • This is no real surprise to those of us from the area. Arlington is a nightmare – 350,000+ people in a 100% car-dependent setting squeezed in between Fort Worth and Dallas.

    Event at the Rangers Ballpark? Massive traffic jams. Big day at Six Flags? Massive traffic jams. Even a minor accident on any of the major highways through there, like I-30? Massive traffic jams. The Cowboys stadium, given their much larger popularity and ridiculously out-of-scale new stadium + its massive parking lots, will bring the city to its knees. The city’s solution was to get I-30 to undergo a huge, ridiculous widening – so they’ll be really upset when it turns out that all that does is make the traffic jams even more insane than they would have been otherwise.

    And Arlington always turns down transit of any sort, as mentioned in the article. “We don’t want those types” is something that is heard *constantly* in stories about the latest failed bid to do anything, even bus service. The city’s only tentative embrace of transit has been a minor pilot program with Fort Worth’s agency, The T, for some park & ride buses between a parking lot in Arlington and Downtown Fort Worth.

    That’s actually a big problem for Fort Worth – The T barely has enough money to fund the mediocre bus service it runs here. Unlike DART, which has gotten several neighboring cities to Dallas to join the agency and contribute funding, The T only has Fort Worth and suburb Richland Hills. The other area cities contribute their small percentage of sales tax that they could use to join The T to other efforts like getting strip malls built with tax breaks, so The T’s stuck in this sort of unchanging swamp of mediocrity. They’re working on trying to get a second commuter rail line going, the Southwest-to-Northeast line, and several cities that the line passes through either don’t want to join or only want to contract for a rail station rather than become full members.

    It’s telling that the planned Fort Worth modern streetcar system basically has nothing at all to do with The T.

  • Here is an update, parking at the Dallas Cowboy dome is a nightmare for automobiles so pedicabs started to help out. Both the City of Arlington and the Dallas Cowboys threw them off the premises.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Living Up to the Nation’s Transit Potential

|
Today on the Streetsblog Network, we’ve got a post about unfulfilled potential — American cities that could do a lot better at getting people to ride transit. The Transit Pass compares the cities with the top ridership to those with the top population: Riders boarding light rail in Phoenix. Photo by Michael Ruiz via Flickr. […]
STREETSBLOG USA

How to Make Transit Succeed in a Sprawling City

|
In many ways, Calgary, Canada’s third-largest city, is very much like a sprawling American city. But in one way, it’s very different: It’s a huge transit city. Despite being composed mostly of sprawling single-family homes, in this Canadian energy boomtown, 50 percent of downtown workers arrive by transit and another 11 percent by bike — way […]
STREETSBLOG USA

Parking Madness Final Four: Federal Way vs. Dallas

|
Villanova is taking on UNC tonight, but the main event is here on Streetsblog, with the first Final Four match of Parking Madness 2016. Streetsblog readers have narrowed this year’s field of 16 down to four parking abominations in these cities: Niagara Falls, Louisville, Dallas, and Federal Way, Washington. Your votes will determine who gets into the […]