What’s Next for New York State DOT?

glynn.jpgState DOT Commissioner Astrid Glynn

On Monday, state DOT Commissioner Astrid Glynn tendered her resignation, leaving the agency’s top job during a critical period for statewide transportation policy. Governor Paterson engineered Glynn’s departure, according to the Daily News, following her three-week vacation to Borneo that came while DOT is still deciding how to spend its pot of federal stimulus cash. With state politicians also discussing solutions for the MTA budget crisis in tandem with funding for the state’s road and bridge program, crucial decisions will take shape without an established leader at the helm of the transportation agency.

"It comes at a tough time," Neysa Pranger of the Regional Plan Association said of Glynn’s departure. "It complicates things if there’s a leadership change at the head of DOT."

Progressive transportation advocates credit Glynn, who was appointed by Eliot Spitzer in 2007, with introducing a gradual shift in culture at the state DOT. "She didn’t start whipping everyone into shape immediately," said Tri-State Transportation Campaign director Kate Slevin. "She took a more measured approach."

One of the more noticeable changes transpired at DOT’s District 10 office, which covers Nassau and Suffolk counties. "Before Glynn took over, we would fight every single road project," said Eric Alexander, director of the smart growth organization Vision Long Island. "Communities would say,
‘We don’t want your transportation money, take your checks back.’"

The DOT’s plan to convert 15 miles of an east-west state road, Route 347, into a high-speed, limited access highway had met with particularly vociferous opposition for the better part of the past ten years. Under Glynn’s leadership, says Alexander, the change at the regional office "was like night and day." Smart growth advocates had a seat at the table. A new plan for 347 unveiled in January would create a "suburban boulevard" with a lower design speed, planted median, bus shelters, and a pedestrian and bicycle path. The regional office is now talking to businesses about building infill on big parking lots that line the road.

Glynn’s DOT had its lapses — witness the changes underway on the Staten Island Expressway, where $40 million in stimulus cash will be spent on auxiliary lanes and ramp adjustments, and a formerly exclusive busway just opened up to private cars — and in terms of institutional change, it didn’t match the rapid pace at New York City DOT under Janette Sadik-Khan. But the overall direction of the agency boded well for more sustainable transportation and land use policies in the state. Advocates hope her successor will build on that momentum and strengthen new programs like the "Smart Planning" initiative, an attempt to foster smart growth practices among municipalities.

Glynn’s resignation takes effect May 8, with first deputy commissioner Stanley Gee slated to take over until Paterson names a replacement. The next commissioner, says Alexander, should be someone "who’s looking at best practices, instead of old practices. The last thing
you want to do is take a step back."

  • The next commissioner, says Alexander, should be someone “who’s looking at best practices, instead of old practices. The last thing you want to do is take a step back.”

    Actually, “old” practices sometimes are the best practice, if by “old” you mean older than the automobile age. I guess that’s what he meant, right? One of my pet peeves is that we often avoid perfectly good solutions that have been in place elsewhere forever in favor of reinventing the wheel, AKA the “Not Invented Here” syndrome.

  • Glenn

    Agreed – pre-1920 urban planning was quite good at integrating good architecture, mixed use and efficient transportation systems. Most of the improvements in basic hygiene have also been a plus. The air conditioner has been a mixed blessing. While it’s really great when you’re stuck inside, it tends to keep people inside when the streets used to be full of people.

    NJ’s DOT has done some really good work with helping build real village plans around train stations and creating intermodal hubs. There’s a lot that could be done around the state.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Streetfilms: NYSDOT Commish on Smart Growth and Stimulus

|
One thing we’ve learned from the stimulus saga is that many state DOTs still haven’t kicked the highway habit. New York’s state DOT is one of the exceptions: Expansion projects are mercifully absent from its stimulus wish list, according to a recent analysis by the Tri-State Transportation Campaign. Under Commissioner Astrid Glynn, the agency is […]

Polly Trottenberg Tapped For Senior U.S. DOT Spot

|
It’s a happy Friday for transportation wonks: the White House has nominated Polly Trottenberg, executive director of Building America’s Future, as assistant secretary for policy at the federal DOT. Polly Trottenberg, tapped as assistant DOT secretary (Photo: NewTalk) Trottenberg’s ascension signals that the Obama administration will make transit a serious priority and encourage a more […]

Eight Ways State DOT Chief Joan McDonald Can Make New York Better

|
“By building more and more roads, we have made it almost impossible to solve our transportation problems” – Allen Biehler, Secretary, Pennsylvania DOT and Chair, AASHTO Standing Committee on Highways Every state Department of Transportation (DOT) is led by a chief executive. In some states, they’re called the “secretary.” In others, the “director.” In New […]

Panel: ‘Meeting the Challenges of Growth’

|
As part of its annual meeting, the New York Metropolitan Transportaiton Council will be holding a panel discussion entitled "Meeting the Challenges of Growth." The panel will include: Daniel L. Doctoroff, Deputy Mayor for Economic Development and Rebuilding Astrid C. Glynn, Acting Commissioner, New York State DOT Elliot G. Sander, Executive Director and CEO, MTA

Today’s Headlines

|
MTA Budget Hole Bigger Than Expected, Second Round of Cuts on the Horizon (NYT, News, Post) State DOT Commish Astrid Glynn Resigns Her Post (Daily Politics, Times Union, WNYC) Obama Boasts of 2,000 Stim-Funded Transportation Projects (WaPo) TLC Mulls Split Fares, Cellphone-Blocking, and Other Tech for Cabs (Post, News) Study Feeds Safety Fears of Small […]

Streetfilms: Building Greenways and Community in the Bronx

|
This Streetfilm from Robin Urban Smith and Elizabeth Press brings us an update on the state of greenway development in the Bronx. Writes Robin: The Bronx River Greenway and South Bronx Greenway plans apply community-driven design strategies to help undo years of top down, auto-centric planning and development in the Bronx. The greenways, when completed, […]