Victims’ Families to Morgenthau: Prosecute Driver for Deadly Negligence

On the morning of January 22, Diego Martinez and Hayley Ng were walking with their preschool class on East Broadway when an unattended delivery van jumped the curb in reverse and killed them. The three-ton vehicle had been left double-parked and idling by its operator before it backed onto the sidewalk with deadly force. To date, Manhattan District Attorney Robert Morgenthau has taken no action to prosecute the driver.

About 70 New Yorkers joined the families of Hayley and Diego today and called on the DA to convene a grand jury to investigate the case. Gathered outside the DA’s office in Lower Manhattan, they made an impassioned plea for justice.

"I cannot understand why the Manhattan District Attorney refuses to prosecute," said Hayley’s cousin, Lauren Ng, on behalf of the victim’s mother, May Ng. "Accidents happen, but someone still bears the burden of responsibility. What kind of city is this that does not protect its most vulnerable citizens?"

The public servants who oversee the justice system seldom prosecute deadly drivers unless drugs or alcohol are involved, despite the human toll they exact. Traffic violence claims the life of a New Yorker, on average, every 36
hours, and vehicles injure more than 10,000 pedestrians and cyclists
every year, according to DMV statistics cited by Transportation Alternatives. "We want our district attorney to prosecute dangerous and negligent drivers as aggressively as drunk drivers," said TA director Paul White. "The driver didn’t mean to kill those children, but by not prosecuting, we’re sending the message that it’s okay to operate heavy machinery on the streets of New York without due care."

Relatives of Diego and Hayley say the DA’s office has told them that their "hands are tied" in this case. But existing statutes for criminal negligence could be used to prosecute drivers in this set of circumstances, said Jon Adler, head of the Federal Law Enforcement Officers Association, speaking on behalf of the victims’ families. "We cannot turn our backs and condone reckless driving," Adler said. "A reasonable person would turn off the vehicle. When you do that, it’s a paper weight; when you don’t, it’s a killing machine."

Video: Elizabeth Press

  • Evan

    Why is it that drivers always get a free pass for committing a crime?
    In this nation driven by liability, cars are somehow immune.
    What gives?

  • Michelle

    i agree. that driver should take responsibility. even though it is an accident there are people now suffering because of him not being responsible

  • (N)

    Of course I agree; responsibility and liability for drivers! That said, what exactly does that mean? Does locking someone up deter “accidents”? Does it come in the form of financial cost? Aren’t there are civil courts for that?

    Yes, this incident is egregious. I’m no crime or law professional, but I suspect this incident points out the inadequacies of our justice system more than our enforcement nets, don’t you think?

  • (N): “Of course I agree; responsibility and liability for drivers! That said, what exactly does that mean? Does locking someone up deter ‘accidents’? Does it come in the form of financial cost? Aren’t there are civil courts for that?

    Perhaps it means much tighter licensing requirements. You kill, you lose your license. I think that would be a stronger deterrent than the distant possibility of a criminal prosecution. The rule would operate as impersonally and objectively as the one that prevents 10-year-olds from driving.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Grieving Chinatown Families to Morgenthau: We’re Not Going Away

|
Relatives of Hayley Ng and Diego Martinez, two preschoolers struck and killed by a van in Chinatown on January 22, continue to demand justice from Manhattan District Attorney Robert Morgenthau. On WCBS television this week, Hayley’s aunt, Wendy Cheung, reiterated both families’ call for citizens to contact Morgenthau’s office and demand further action in the […]

Monday: Rally for Traffic Justice at Manhattan DA’s Office

|
We’re re-posting the notice for this demonstration, which is back on for Monday after being postponed due to the snowstorm earlier this week. Note that the rally is on for noon, not earlier in the day as previously scheduled. The families of Hayley Ng and Diego Martinez, the two preschoolers killed by a van while […]

Manhattan DA Cy Vance Unveils Strategy to Expand Traffic Safety Resources

|
During last year’s campaign for Manhattan District Attorney, Cy Vance came out with a broad traffic safety platform, promising to beef up investigations into deaths caused by drivers. Many of those commitments turned into official policy today, as Vance announced a significant expansion of the DA’s vehicular crimes unit. Vance also pledged to support state […]

District Attorneys Can Start Enforcing Hayley and Diego’s Law Today

|
Hayley and Diego’s Law takes effect today, giving law enforcement a new tool to use against dangerous drivers. With this law, district attorneys throughout New York state can bring the charge of “careless driving” against motorists who irresponsibly injure pedestrians and cyclists. In 2008 alone, traffic crashes killed 344 pedestrians and cyclists in New York […]