Kellner to Ravitch: Don’t Bother Proposing East River Bridge Tolls

kellner.jpgAdd Micah Kellner’s name to the MTA doomsday scorecard. Yesterday, the Upper East Side Assembly member came out in favor of increasing license and registration fees for New York drivers as a transit revenue booster.

Under the Kellner plan, which originated with the non-profit Citizens Budget Commission, motorists would pay flat fees, rather than the weight-based assessments recently proposed by city comptroller William Thompson. Kellner says the new fees would raise $550 million a year — a little more than the income projected from tolls on the now "free" East River bridges.

On that note, Kellner’s press release includes this odd passage:

"Early indications suggest that the Ravitch Commission will announce Friday that tolls on the East River bridges are the centerpiece of their recommendations. This is a proposal that has been recycled time and again in each and every fiscal crisis but has always failed to gain the necessary support to be implemented. I don’t know why they think this time will be any different, but I am hopeful that the Governor’s office will look to other ideas like this one and reinstituting the commuter tax as he constructs his Executive budget."

Could it be that the idea of imposing East River bridge tolls is "recycled time and again" because it’s a proven and equitable course of action? Rather than take a stance for or against, Kellner characterizes new tolls as a non-starter — as if, as an elected state representative, he himself is in no position to influence the issue.

Sounds all too familiar.

  • fdr

    Kellner characterizes new tolls as a non-starter because he knows the elected state representatives from the outer boroughs won’t vote for bridge tolls any more than they would vote for congestion pricing.

  • Marty Barfowitz

    …any more than suburban representatives will vote for a commuter tax!

    Micah’s proposal is a non-starter too. How about that?!

    I suppose Micah knows that with the Republicans nearly deposed in Albany this is all coming down to a “millionaire tax,” more taxes on corporations and fare increases for transit riders (which can be blamed on the evil MTA).

    I suppose Micah also knows that if there’s one Assembly district in the entire city where that might not play very well it’s his own. I hear they’ve got a few millionaires and corporate employees and transit riders up there on the Upper East Side. Thank goodness for Micah that most of them are oblivious to what he’s (not) doing in Albany…

    They can vote once more for a State Assembly representative who is more than willing to abdicate his own personal leadership to whatever happens to be the “political reality.” I’m calling him Micah Mouse from now on.

    I mean, really: What would it cost this guy to go out on a limb and say we’ve got to get behind Ravitch?

  • Larry Littlefield

    There is a great three-part series on the destruction of New Jersey due to pensions over on the Star Ledger blog. The first part is here…

    http://blog.nj.com/njv_johnbury/2008/11/rip_new_jersey_state_pension_p.html

    and has a great, great, great quote that also applies to NY’s pensions, the funding of the MTA, other federal, state and local governments, Wall Street, many other businesses, many people’s personal finances, etc.

    “There is a scene in Mel Brooks’ The Producers where Gene Wilder realizes the jig is up and starts intoning ‘no way out’ while clutching his blankie since, being a reasonably learned accountant, he grasps the situation. Zero Mostel however, whose schemes got them into their mess, still thinks there are outs. That’s how an unbiased pension actuary would feel looking at the state of the New Jersey pension plan. It’s effectively dead but we still have the Zeroes who got us into this mess running around selling more hopes and dreams.”

    Same with the MTA.

    And while they are selling those hope and dreams (remember the 50-year transit plan?) they are sucking more money out for those that matter.

  • Isn’t it true that the rate of car ownership is decreasing among the NYC voting public? Isn’t the percentage of voters that drive across the bridges often enough to care about tolls decreasing? With a growing population in a territory that is not growing, and that has already maxed out on space available to cars, it can’t be otherwise. And besides, successive generations don’t have the same enthusiasm for exhaust spewing machines that baby boomers do. We know that the only way we’ll ever see an “open road” is if people stop driving all the time. (I wouldn’t mind an open road or two, on special occasions.) Kellner’s defeatist “time and again” refrain only holds water if transportation has not changed and isn’t changing, across all the boroughs: that’s not the case by a long shot.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Pols Skeptical Ahead of Ravitch Report Release

|
The much-anticipated report from the Ravitch Commission is scheduled to be released within the hour. The report is expected to include recommendations for an eight percent increase in transit fares along with tolls on East River and, possibly, Harlem River bridges — measures deemed necessary to avert the MTA "doomsday" scenario of a 23 percent […]

What Will It Take for Assemblyman Kellner to Vote for Pricing?

|
Two weeks ago, State Assemblyman Micah Kellner submitted a report to the Traffic Congestion Mitigation Commission [pdf] detailing his concerns about the two pricing plans in the TCMC’s interim report. Kellner’s district encompasses both of the congestion zone’s proposed northern boundaries, running from 60th Street to about 90th Street, and from 3rd Avenue to the […]

Shelly’s Toll Plan: Promise Beyond the Headlines

|
It’s too early to know if Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver’s answer to the Ravitch Commission MTA bailout plan, which includes $2 tolls on East and Harlem River bridges, will make it through the state legislature. But, despite raising less money and reducing traffic much less than congestion pricing or peak-hour tolling would, the plan is […]

Needed: A Better Way to Sweeten the Ravitch Plan

|
Wondering how the revised version of the Ravitch plan compares to what’s come before? Here’s a look at the tweaks proposed yesterday by the Ravitch Commission: East and Harlem River bridge tolls of $2.16 each way with EZ Pass, $2.50 without. 50-cent taxi fare surcharge. A higher tax rate on parking in Manhattan. Revenue from […]

More on the Ravitch Commission’s MTA Fix

|
Photo: New York Times Brad hit the major points from today’s Ravitch/Paterson/Bloomberg press conference. Here are some more details on the MTA rescue plan they unveiled. (The whole Ravitch Commission report is available as a PDF.) Bridge tolls would be cashless, using E-ZPass and license plate capture technology, not toll booths. The city would transfer […]

Where They Stand, Or Don’t: The MTA Doomsday Scorecard

|
Rhetorically speaking, it’s often easier to be against something than to stand in support of it. This could be why, with one or two possible exceptions, the political players in the MTA "doomsday" drama have so far gained the most media attention by, say, shouting down bridge tolls (Yay!) or getting a shoe shine (Boo!). […]