Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
MTA

Crain’s: East River Bridge Tolls Should Complement Commuter Tax

10:52 AM EST on November 25, 2008

On Sunday, the editors of Crain's proposed that a reinstatement of the commuter tax, as called for by several local pols -- including Sheldon Silver, who helped kill it in 1999 -- should be considered in concert with, and not instead of, tolls on East River bridges. The editorial is behind the pay wall, so here is an excerpt:

Soaking suburbanites to reduce the burden on city residents is a political nonstarter ... Anend to the political stalemate requires recognizing that both sides inthis debate have strong arguments. There is some truth to the belief ofNew York City residents that suburbanites use many city services andshould contribute something to the city in which they work. Commutersare also right in saying they already pay their share with purchasesthat boost sales taxes. In addition, their state taxes are divertedfrom the wealthy suburbs to the city.

So what common interestsdo the two groups share? The desire to preserve affordable masstransit, something that is in jeopardy given the MTA's huge budgetdeficit and its proposal to hike fares by 23%. The sensible compromiseis to adopt both the commuter tax and East River tolls and dedicate themoney to the MTA to hold down fare increases and fund a vitally neededcapital program.

Crain's is right in that city-based politicians have nothing to lose by proposing a tax on those outside their districts, while asking nothing of their own car-commuting constituents who also benefit from a thriving mass transit system. But will any of them step up and recommend both?

Brad Aaron
Brad Aaron began writing for Streetsblog in 2007, after years as a reporter, editor, and publisher in the alternative weekly business. Brad adopted New York'’s dysfunctional traffic justice system as his primary beat for Streetsblog. He lives in Manhattan.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Congestion Pricing

Tuesday’s Headlines: Valley of Political Death Edition

Did you see the new poll showing congestion pricing is really unpopular? Ignore it! Good times are coming. Plus other news in today's headlines.

April 23, 2024
Open Streets

Open Streets Groups Warn of Extra Red Tape to Run Events

Two weeks notice for hopscotch or a yoga class?

April 23, 2024
NYPD

Monday’s Headlines: A Federal Case over Parking Edition

We're flicking our bicycle bell over a big scoop last week that no one picked up on...yet. Plus other news.

April 22, 2024
Tolls

Hochul, Legislators Reach Toll Evasion Crackdown Deal

Higher fines for covering a plate and for not paying tolls are part of the budget deal inked on Saturday.

April 22, 2024
Speed limits

Behind the Scenes: How Gov. Hochul Got ‘Sammy’s Law’ Over the Finish Line

Opponents didn't want to put their name on a no vote for the life-saving measure.

April 22, 2024
See all posts