Parking Reform Alone Won’t Solve Congestion

Room Eight contributor and Streetsblog commenter Larry Littlefield has a thorough critique of the congestion pricing alternatives released last week by anti-pricing group Keep NYC Congestion Tax Free. 

Proponents of congestion pricing, who would probably otherwise support
many the alternative’s ideas, immediately blasted it for being what it
probably is –- a red herring designed to ensure that nothing 203396002_f378185804.jpghappens,
existing privileges are maintained, and problems are not solved, but
the public is confused about who is to blame and thus just shrugs its
shoulders. The typical Albany win over the public, in other words.
Still, there is enough of interest in the proposal that it deserves a
thoughtful review, and such a review finds that it is essentially an
extension of current policies, and has the same hole as those policies. 

Since most of these are sensible measures they shouldn’t be rejected
out of hand. But they don’t do anything to discourage through traffic,
an issue the opponents acknowledge. Even so, the congestion pricing opponents, in recommending variable
tolls for peak and non-peak hours and higher costs for parking have
accepted the concept of using pricing to limit the over-use of a scarce
resource, a large leap for them to make if they have in fact made it.
Perhaps they should be given a little credit rather than just ignored.

Here is the complete article

Photo: roinks/Flickr

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

The Comptroller Race: Who Will Stand Up for Transit?

|
John Liu and David Yassky might be headed for a run-off in the comptroller race. We’ve got two more citywide elections to review on the eve of tomorrow’s primary vote — the contests for comptroller and public advocate. If you’re a little unclear about what these positions do, here’s the short version: The comptroller is […]

TSTC.org Would Be More Thankful If…

|
The Tri-State Transportation Campaign’s new Mobilizing the Region blog is really starting to come alive. If you haven’t added it to your daily news feed yet, it’s probably time to do it. After giving thanks for the transportation policy advances of 2007 on Thursday, the TSTC staff, engorged with Tofurkey, went back to work on […]

Compromise “Ruled the Day” at Congestion Pricing Hearings

|
#Persons %Persons Position 39 26% Support congestion pricing as proposed by Mayor Bloomberg in April 2007 PlaNYC proposal 46 31% Support the concept of pricing, have concerns and recommend changes/additions to Mayor Bloomberg’s proposal 13 9% Express serious concerns with the current proposal and offer suggestions for improvement 39 26% Oppose congestion pricing, suggest other […]

New Spin: Save the Mayor’s Congestion Plan by Modifying It

|
Congestion Mitigation Commission chairman Marc Shaw has a big job ahead of him. Newsflash from Crain’s New York: Congestion pricing is politically challenging: While I don’t think any Streetsblog reader will be shocked by that big scoop, there are still some interesting tidbits in here. The Traffic Mitigation Commission has a new mandate, Greg David […]