Lecture: High-Speed Rail in the United States: Can the Dream Be Realized?

Remarks by Allison L. C. de Cerreño, Ph.D.
Director, NYU Wagner Rudin Center for Transportation Policy and Management
New York University

Many European and Asian countries have implemented or plan to implement high-speed rail (HSR) and/or Maglev. Though U.S. efforts have spanned 40 years, nothing comparable has been implemented in the United States to date. This presentation is based on the findings of two studies funded by the Mineta Transportation Institute that used a combination of literature review and interviews to derive lessons from the U.S. experience. Touching on the Chicago Hub, the Florida, Keystone, and Northeast Corridors, this presentation suggests that several factors are critical to success of HSR projects, while lack of them has led to repeated failures. Based on the research, this paper questions whether the two limited U.S. successes can be replicated without ownership of the right of way by a single passenger rail entity and whether incremental HSR efforts are more likely to succeed in the current political climate.

  • Angus Grieve-Smith

    I like how this is a 35-minute bus ride from the Trenton train station. Or a two-mile walk from the West Trenton train station.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

In Defense of High-Speed Rail

|
Today on the Streetsblog Network, we’ve got a post from Yonah Freemark at The Transport Politic on the importance of funding both intercity and intracity rail, despite limits on the amount of money available. Freemark takes on the argument that investment in transportation within cities should trump the construction of more efficient rail connections between […]
STREETSBLOG USA

High-Speed Rail: Do We Have the Will?

|
Tomorrow morning, I’m getting on a train from Washington, DC to New York. It’s going to take me almost three-and-a-half hours to get there. Sure, I could pay more for an Acela and get there in less than three hours. But why can’t it take 90 minutes? Yesterday, Amtrak unveiled a plan [PDF] to build […]
STREETSBLOG USA

APTA: How to Talk to a Detractor of High-Speed Rail

|
Stop me if you’ve heard these before: “Most Americans don’t use railroads, they use cars.” “There’s no better example of excessive government spending than the $53 billion President Obama allocated for high-speed rail in his 2012 budget.” “Would you pay $1,000 so that someone — probably not you — can ride high-speed trains 58 miles […]
STREETSBLOG USA

How “Buy America” Restrictions Can Cost America Jobs

|
Proponents of Buy America restrictions — regulations that require American-made sourcing for transportation projects supported by the federal government — may be well-meaning, but when applied to rail expansion, these rules can be pretty pernicious. There isn’t a large domestic passenger rail market in the United States, so there isn’t much of a domestic traincar […]